Weather Banter

Weather Banter (https://www.weather-banter.co.uk/)
-   uk.sci.weather (UK Weather) (https://www.weather-banter.co.uk/uk-sci-weather-uk-weather/)
-   -   Highest Pressure since March (https://www.weather-banter.co.uk/uk-sci-weather-uk-weather/136936-highest-pressure-since-march.html)

Rob Brooks September 10th 09 03:59 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my pressure
readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in Leeds since 17
March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.



Col September 10th 09 04:07 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my pressure
readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in Leeds since
17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be more
'intense' than a summer one?
--
Col

Bolton, Lancashire
160m asl



Will Hand September 10th 09 04:15 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be more
'intense' than a summer one?


dynamics lesson
Why? And don't say because the air is colder as that would not be the right
answer, this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in the
dynamics - this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent relaxing
upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of upper level
convergence due to ageostrophic wind components. Also we had a deep low with
a lot of wind and kinetic energy which has been converted to potential
energy helping to raise pressure substantially. This is a warm and intense
high.
/dynamics lesson

Will
--



Col September 10th 09 04:25 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be
more
'intense' than a summer one?


dynamics lesson
Why? And don't say because the air is colder as that would not be the
right answer, this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in
the dynamics - this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent
relaxing upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of
upper level convergence due to ageostrophic wind components. Also we had a
deep low with a lot of wind and kinetic energy which has been converted to
potential energy helping to raise pressure substantially. This is a warm
and intense high.
/dynamics lesson


Will, I don't understand any of that :)
--
Col

Bolton, Lancashire
160m asl



Paul Hyett September 10th 09 04:51 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On Thu, 10 Sep 2009 at 17:07:48, Col wrote
in uk.sci.weather :


"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my pressure
readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in Leeds since
17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be more
'intense' than a summer one?


I wouldn't quite call this winter yet :) - mind you, the temperature did
drop to 4.6C last night...
--
Paul Hyett, Cheltenham (change 'invalid83261' to 'blueyonder' to email me)

Will Hand September 10th 09 08:11 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.

Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be
more
'intense' than a summer one?


dynamics lesson
Why? And don't say because the air is colder as that would not be the
right answer, this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in
the dynamics - this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent
relaxing upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of
upper level convergence due to ageostrophic wind components. Also we had
a deep low with a lot of wind and kinetic energy which has been converted
to potential energy helping to raise pressure substantially. This is a
warm and intense high.
/dynamics lesson


Will, I don't understand any of that :)
--


Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

To put it more simply, two upper air flow patterns occurred close together
where the wind flows were such that they produced a coming together of air
high up in the atmosphere at around 30000 feet. This air was forced to come
down as the tropopause higher up was acting as a lid. This downward motion
transported masses of air into one place and pressure began to rise at the
surface. Meanwhile at the same time a very deep low began to fill up and the
kinetic energy of the fast moving air was converting to potential energy
(energy is never lost) reinforcing the effect of the coming together of the
air flows.

Is that better?

Will
--


Stephen Burt[_2_] September 10th 09 09:45 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On 10 Sep, 21:11, "Will Hand" wrote:


Will, I don't understand any of that :)
--


Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

Is that better?


Will



What an utterly pretentious response that is, Will. Please grow up and
have some respect for the majority on this newsgroup who don't have
your background but who are asking perfectly reasonable questions in
order to seek greater understanding and not to be used as target
practice for patronising statements such as the ones above. I suggest
an apology to Col is in order.

--
Stephen Burt
Stratfield Mortimer, Berkshire

paulus September 10th 09 10:26 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Stephen Burt" wrote in message
...
On 10 Sep, 21:11, "Will Hand" wrote:


Will, I don't understand any of that :)
--


Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

Is that better?


Will



What an utterly pretentious response that is, Will. Please grow up and
have some respect for the majority on this newsgroup who don't have
your background but who are asking perfectly reasonable questions in
order to seek greater understanding and not to be used as target
practice for patronising statements such as the ones above. I suggest
an apology to Col is in order.

--
Stephen Burt
Stratfield Mortimer, Berkshire


I didn't understand too much of that either but as this is the "uk.sci"
heirachy of usenet I guess a bit of science is to be expected.

Paul


Bernard Burton September 10th 09 10:28 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 
Yes Will, that's OK for the dynamics. But the next step is to equate this to
the physical consequence, the thermodynamic effect, of the dynamics you
describe. The effect of the upper level convergence is to lift a substantial
layer of the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere, which of course
results in a cooling of the layer, especially well marked in the
stratosphere, where the lapse is zero or negative. It is this cooling that
more than compensates for the tropospheric warming due to subsidence and
advection, and produces the increase in pressure at the base of the
atmosphere. Mass can only increase in an atmospheric column if there is a
corresponding decrease in temperature. A map of the pressure or height field
at any level in the atmosphere is a direct reflection of the mean
temperature field (or thickness) in the atmosphere above that level. A high
pressure 'cell' at any level will be a reflection of a cold anomaly above
that level, and a warm anomaly will be found above a low pressure area.

--
Bernard Burton
Wokingham, Berkshire, UK.

Satellite images at:
www.woksat.info/wwp.html

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be

more
'intense' than a summer one?


dynamics lesson
Why? And don't say because the air is colder as that would not be the

right
answer, this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in the
dynamics - this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent

relaxing
upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of upper level
convergence due to ageostrophic wind components. Also we had a deep low

with
a lot of wind and kinetic energy which has been converted to potential
energy helping to raise pressure substantially. This is a warm and intense
high.
/dynamics lesson

Will
--





Tudor Hughes September 11th 09 02:44 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On Sep 10, 11:28*pm, "Bernard Burton" b.j.burton-
wrote:
Yes Will, that's OK for the dynamics. But the next step is to equate this to
the physical consequence, the thermodynamic effect, of the dynamics you
describe. The effect of the upper level convergence is to lift a substantial
layer of the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere, which of course
results in a cooling of the layer, especially well marked in the
stratosphere, where the lapse is zero or negative. It is this cooling that
more than compensates for the tropospheric warming due to subsidence and
advection, and produces the increase in pressure at the base of the
atmosphere. Mass can only increase in an atmospheric column if there is a
corresponding decrease in temperature. A map of the pressure or height field
at any level in the atmosphere is a direct reflection of the mean
temperature field (or thickness) in the atmosphere above *that level. A high
pressure 'cell' at any level will be a reflection of a cold anomaly above
that level, and a warm anomaly will be found above a low pressure area.

--
Bernard Burton
Wokingham, Berkshire, UK.

Satellite images at:www.woksat.info/wwp.html

"Will Hand" wrote in message

...





"Col" wrote in message
...


"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be

more
'intense' than a summer one?


dynamics lesson
Why? And don't say because the air is colder as that would not be the

right
answer, this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in the
dynamics - this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent

relaxing
upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of upper level
convergence due to ageostrophic wind components. Also we had a deep low

with
a lot of wind and kinetic energy which has been converted to potential
energy helping to raise pressure substantially. This is a warm and intense
high.
/dynamics lesson


Will
--- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Thank goodness someone has come up with a lucid explanation of
where the extra air is, to put it simply. i used to be a bit puzzled
about this. If you go to 30,000 feet in an anticyclone the pressure
is still higher than normal for that height so one is still forced to
ask oneself where all this "extra air" is. Above 30,000 feet,
obviously. I knew it must be in the stratosphere but it is now clear
to me how it gets there and why it causes high pressure. One could
say that the dynamical processes try to lift the lid and the lid
fights back with adiabatic cooling.
It's all a bit clearer now. Thanks, Bernard.

Tudor Hughes, Warlingham, Surrey.


Paul Hyett September 11th 09 07:28 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On Thu, 10 Sep 2009 at 17:15:01, Will Hand
wrote in uk.sci.weather :

this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in the dynamics
- this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent relaxing
upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of upper
level convergence due to ageostrophic wind components.


Ow - my head hurts. :p
--
Paul Hyett, Cheltenham (change 'invalid83261' to 'blueyonder' to email me)

Col September 11th 09 07:42 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Stephen Burt" wrote in message
...
On 10 Sep, 21:11, "Will Hand" wrote:


Will, I don't understand any of that :)
--


Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

Is that better?


Will



What an utterly pretentious response that is, Will. Please grow up and
have some respect for the majority on this newsgroup who don't have
your background but who are asking perfectly reasonable questions in
order to seek greater understanding and not to be used as target
practice for patronising statements such as the ones above. I suggest
an apology to Col is in order.


Eh?
I thought that was a perfectly reasonable response, I didn't think it was
patronising at all. He used a smiley which to me means that it was a
light-hearted comment, nothing to take offence at.
--
Col

Bolton, Lancashire
160m asl



Col September 11th 09 07:43 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...



Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

To put it more simply, two upper air flow patterns occurred close together
where the wind flows were such that they produced a coming together of air
high up in the atmosphere at around 30000 feet. This air was forced to
come down as the tropopause higher up was acting as a lid. This downward
motion transported masses of air into one place and pressure began to rise
at the surface. Meanwhile at the same time a very deep low began to fill
up and the kinetic energy of the fast moving air was converting to
potential energy (energy is never lost) reinforcing the effect of the
coming together of the air flows.

Is that better?


Yes, thanks!
--
Col

Bolton, Lancashire
160m asl



Will Hand September 11th 09 08:18 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Stephen Burt" wrote in message
...
On 10 Sep, 21:11, "Will Hand" wrote:


Will, I don't understand any of that :)
--


Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

Is that better?


Will



What an utterly pretentious response that is, Will. Please grow up and
have some respect for the majority on this newsgroup who don't have
your background but who are asking perfectly reasonable questions in
order to seek greater understanding and not to be used as target
practice for patronising statements such as the ones above. I suggest
an apology to Col is in order.


It was a joke Stephen - a joke.

This is not the first time you have had a pop at me in public, and you an ex
Met Office person as well, who now works for Dell (at least last time we
spoke you did). Also we were friends once and Helen is a godparent to one of
my children - remember that?

You will notice that I did offer a less technical explanation - I didn't
have to do that.
Can I suggest you sort yourself out first before making such rash statements
in public.

Will
--



Will Hand September 11th 09 08:23 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...



Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or the
Met. degree at Reading :-)

To put it more simply, two upper air flow patterns occurred close
together where the wind flows were such that they produced a coming
together of air high up in the atmosphere at around 30000 feet. This air
was forced to come down as the tropopause higher up was acting as a lid.
This downward motion transported masses of air into one place and
pressure began to rise at the surface. Meanwhile at the same time a very
deep low began to fill up and the kinetic energy of the fast moving air
was converting to potential energy (energy is never lost) reinforcing the
effect of the coming together of the air flows.

Is that better?


Yes, thanks!
--


Cheers Col.

Will
--


Will Hand September 11th 09 08:28 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
Thanks Bernard. I didn't mean to neglect the thermodynamics. I was trying to
illustrate the fact that intense highs are not entirely due to very cold
dense air near the surface as a lot of people believe.

Will
--

"Bernard Burton" wrote in message
...
Yes Will, that's OK for the dynamics. But the next step is to equate this
to
the physical consequence, the thermodynamic effect, of the dynamics you
describe. The effect of the upper level convergence is to lift a
substantial
layer of the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere, which of course
results in a cooling of the layer, especially well marked in the
stratosphere, where the lapse is zero or negative. It is this cooling that
more than compensates for the tropospheric warming due to subsidence and
advection, and produces the increase in pressure at the base of the
atmosphere. Mass can only increase in an atmospheric column if there is a
corresponding decrease in temperature. A map of the pressure or height
field
at any level in the atmosphere is a direct reflection of the mean
temperature field (or thickness) in the atmosphere above that level. A
high
pressure 'cell' at any level will be a reflection of a cold anomaly above
that level, and a warm anomaly will be found above a low pressure area.

--
Bernard Burton
Wokingham, Berkshire, UK.

Satellite images at:
www.woksat.info/wwp.html

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.

Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be

more
'intense' than a summer one?


dynamics lesson
Why? And don't say because the air is colder as that would not be the

right
answer, this high has 552DAM air entrained. The reason is all in the
dynamics - this high developed at the left entrance of a confluent

relaxing
upper trough and right exit of an Atlantic jet both regions of upper
level
convergence due to ageostrophic wind components. Also we had a deep low

with
a lot of wind and kinetic energy which has been converted to potential
energy helping to raise pressure substantially. This is a warm and
intense
high.
/dynamics lesson

Will
--






Mike Tullett[_2_] September 11th 09 08:29 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On Fri, 11 Sep 2009 09:18:02 +0100, Will Hand wrote in


What an utterly pretentious response that is, Will. Please grow up and
have some respect for the majority on this newsgroup who don't have
your background but who are asking perfectly reasonable questions in
order to seek greater understanding and not to be used as target
practice for patronising statements such as the ones above. I suggest
an apology to Col is in order.


It was a joke Stephen - a joke.


That's exactly how I read it and you then took the time to simplify the
dynamics of the process in the subsequent explanation.

I think this shows how the meaning of our words here in print can sometimes
be misconstrued - more so than in an real conversation.

--
Mike Tullett - Coleraine 55.13°N 6.69°W posted 9/11/2009 8:29:43 AM GMT

Alan White September 11th 09 08:39 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On Fri, 11 Sep 2009 09:32:36 +0100, "Will Hand"
wrote:

I would do it more now but I'm afraid of accused of being patronising
because of my writing style, so I don't bother much - it is all very sad.


Don't take it to heart. It was your comment that was thought patronising
not the main content of your post so carry on. Some 'heavy' science
would do this group a power of good at the moment.
--
Alan White
Mozilla Firefox and Forte Agent.
Twenty-eight miles NW of Glasgow, overlooking Lochs Long and Goil in Argyll, Scotland.
Webcam and weather:- http://windycroft.gt-britain.co.uk/weather

Graham P Davis September 11th 09 08:41 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
Paul Hyett wrote:

On Thu, 10 Sep 2009 at 17:07:48, Col wrote
in uk.sci.weather :


"Rob Brooks" wrote in message
...
At long last A High of significance - had a quick look back at my
pressure readings this year and today has seen the highest pressure in
Leeds since 17 March. It's now 1038mb and still rising.


Is this really surprising, though?
In terms of pressure readings isn't a winter anticyclone likely to be more
'intense' than a summer one?


I wouldn't quite call this winter yet :) - mind you, the temperature did
drop to 4.6C last night...


I would have said 17 March is more likely a "winter" anticyclone - only 17
days away from meteorological winter whereas we're about 80 days from it.

--
Graham P Davis, Bracknell, Berks., UK. E-mail: newsman not newsboy
"I wear the cheese. It does not wear me."

Howard Neil September 11th 09 10:56 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 

Will Hand wrote:

"Col" wrote in message
...

"Will Hand" wrote in message
...

"Col" wrote in message
...



Sorry Col, I forgot you hadn't done an advanced forecasting course or
the Met. degree at Reading :-)

To put it more simply, two upper air flow patterns occurred close
together where the wind flows were such that they produced a coming
together of air high up in the atmosphere at around 30000 feet. This
air was forced to come down as the tropopause higher up was acting as
a lid. This downward motion transported masses of air into one place
and pressure began to rise at the surface. Meanwhile at the same time
a very deep low began to fill up and the kinetic energy of the fast
moving air was converting to potential energy (energy is never lost)
reinforcing the effect of the coming together of the air flows.

Is that better?


Yes, thanks!
--


Cheers Col.

Will


The response was very good. More importantly, if anyone was to complain,
it would be Col himself, not anyone else. However, as I never saw the
complainant's post, I can only assume he was in my kill file. If he
hadn't been, he would now. I really hate bullies who think they should
tell everyone else how they should act. You carry on, Will.

--
Howard Neil

Col September 13th 09 07:25 PM

Highest Pressure since March
 

"Howard Neil" wrote in message
o.uk...



The response was very good. More importantly, if anyone was to complain,
it would be Col himself, not anyone else. However, as I never saw the
complainant's post, I can only assume he was in my kill file. If he hadn't
been, he would now. I really hate bullies who think they should tell
everyone else how they should act. You carry on, Will.


Well exactly.
I wasn't offended and found it rather presumptious for somebody
to take it upon themselves to be offended on my behalf, without
even botherthing to wait to see if*I* said anything about it!
--
Col

Bolton, Lancashire
160m asl



Paul Hyett September 14th 09 10:55 AM

Highest Pressure since March
 
On Sun, 13 Sep 2009 at 20:25:49, Col wrote
in uk.sci.weather :

I wasn't offended and found it rather presumptious for somebody
to take it upon themselves to be offended on my behalf, without
even botherthing to wait to see if*I* said anything about it!


Presumably he works for the 'diversity' department of some local
council... :p
--
Paul Hyett, Cheltenham (change 'invalid83261' to 'blueyonder' to email me)


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2006 WeatherBanter.co.uk